

Reviewer Asks You to Cite Their Papers? What Publishers Say
Add a reference a reviewer suggests if it is relevant to your paper, and explain in your response letter why you left out any that aren't. Elsevier tells reviewers not to "Ask authors to cite your work, or your associates', unless there's a genuine academic reason." Sage tells them to avoid asking for citations of their own published work, and Taylor & Francis lists citation requests "without due scholarly justification or relevance" as citation manipulation. If a review pushes a set of papers that have nothing to do with your study, tell the editor. Sage asks authors to report such requests to Sage.
The publisher pages and the Nature Index report below were read on November 17 and 18, 2026.
What publishers tell reviewers about suggesting citations
| Publisher | What its page says |
|---|---|
| Elsevier | In its "Do not" list for reviewers: "Ask authors to cite your work, or your associates', unless there's a genuine academic reason, never to boost citation counts or visibility" |
| Sage | "You should avoid asking" authors "to cite your own published work. Such requests can constitute a conflict of interest and risk the anonymity of peer review." "Suggestions must be based on valid academic or technological reasons." |
| Taylor & Francis | Citation stacking, listed under "Citation manipulation": "where peer reviewers use their review reports on articles ... to increase their own or specific colleagues' citations, or citations to their journals, by requesting authors cite articles without due scholarly justification or relevance" |
Sources: Elsevier (n.d.), Sage (n.d.-b), and Taylor & Francis (n.d.-b).
None of these pages bans suggestions as such. Elsevier asks reviewers of a review article whether it covers "the most relevant, recent advances, including the key research groups," and to "Suggest additions" where "the reference list falls short" (Elsevier, n.d.). Sage puts the reviewer's own work in the same frame: a suggestion has to rest on an academic or technical reason, not on raising "their citation count" (Sage, n.d.-b).
The same pages also cover editors. Taylor & Francis defines coercive citation as cases "where journal Editorial team members coerce or require authors to cite papers from their own previously published articles, or from specific journals (including their own), or specific author groups, without due scholarly justification or relevance, often as a condition of acceptance" (Taylor & Francis, n.d.-b).
What Elsevier's 2019 analysis found
In 2019, Nature reported on an Elsevier analysis of the peer-review activity of almost 55,000 reviewers for its journals, which measured how often each reviewer's work was cited by the papers they reviewed (Singh Chawla, 2019). From the report:
- Around 98.5% of the reviewers were cited in fewer than 10% of the papers they reviewed.
- Less than 1%, the report says, "consistently seem to have their own work referenced in studies they have reviewed."
- "Because reviewers and authors tend to work in the same field, some overlap in citations is expected."
- Elsevier was asking journal editors whether the references in question were relevant.
- Elsevier said studies affected by coercive citation would not need to be retracted, "because the authors aren't responsible for the problem."
The same report says that "Bioinformatics banned a referee from reviewing for the journal" after an investigation found that the referee "had requested an average of 35 additional citations per review, 90% of which were for papers they had co-authored."
By the report's own reasoning, a reviewer's work turning up in your list is expected. What the publishers' pages object to is a request without an academic reason, and the Bioinformatics case involved many requests aimed at the referee's own papers.
How to answer the request in your response letter
The publishers' standard is relevance, so apply it to each suggested reference on its own. Here is how we would handle it:
- Read each suggested paper. Ask whether it supports, contradicts, or adds to a specific point in your manuscript.
- Add the ones that do, at that point, and say where in your response letter.
- For the ones you leave out, give a short reason that is about the content of the paper, such as a different population, method, or question. Keep it factual.
- Don't name the person you think wrote the review. Sage notes that such requests can "risk the anonymity of peer review" (Sage, n.d.-b); your letter should not add to that.
- If the requests look like the pattern above, write to the handling editor, and describe the requests, not the person. Taylor & Francis tells authors: "If you are unsure about whether to cite a source you should contact the journal editorial office for advice" (Taylor & Francis, n.d.-a). Sage says: "Authors are encouraged to report such requests or attempts by peer-reviewers to Sage" (Sage, n.d.-a).
A response written this way could read as follows (our own wording, with placeholder references):
Reviewer 2, comment 4: Thank you for these suggestions. We have added Reference A to Section 2.3, where it supports our choice of measure. We have not added References B to E, which study a different population and do not address our research question.
The editor makes the decision on the manuscript. Action against the reviewer is up to the publisher: Sage says reviewers who use their position "to coerce authors into citing their publications will be removed from the peer-review or decision-making process" (Sage, n.d.-a).
How much self-citation is acceptable?
The publisher pages here don't give a number. They define the problem by justification instead:
- Taylor & Francis: "Excessive self-citation: authors citing their own articles without due scholarly justification or relevance" (Taylor & Francis, n.d.-b).
- Sage: "Excessive self-citation, unnecessary or gift-citations as well as other attempts to manipulate citations activity is a breach of publication ethics" (Sage, n.d.-a).
The same test applies to your own reference list. Taylor & Francis adds: "Your references should not be unfairly biased towards a particular research group, organization or journal" (Taylor & Francis, n.d.-a).
Check every reference you add during revision
References you add in a revision, including ones a reviewer suggested, are your responsibility like the rest of the list. Taylor & Francis: "Authors are responsible for ensuring the integrity of the whole content of their submissions including the accuracy of references," and "References must be valid, accurate (i.e. not hallucinations) and support the stated claims" (Taylor & Francis, n.d.-a). The rest of a resubmission is in the revised manuscript checklist.
Before you resubmit, paste the revised reference list into PerfectRefs; you don't upload the paper. The Existence check looks up each reference in Crossref, OpenAlex, and other scholarly databases and flags any it can't find. It comes with a free daily allowance. The Style check compares authors, title, journal, year, volume, issue, pages, and DOI field by field with the database record, shows the record's values with a link to the source, and lets you accept a fix with one click. It uses premium credits (2 per reference), and new accounts get 10. Whether a reference supports your claim is still yours to judge: PerfectRefs checks that the work exists and that your entry matches its record.
FAQ
Do I have to add every reference a reviewer suggests?
No publisher page above says so. Their test is whether a suggestion has an academic reason. Add the relevant ones, explain the rest in your response, and leave the decision to the editor.
Is coercive citation misconduct?
Taylor & Francis lists it, with citation stacking by reviewers, under "Citation manipulation" on its misconduct page (Taylor & Francis, n.d.-b). Sage removes reviewers who coerce authors from peer review (Sage, n.d.-a).
Can my paper be retracted for citations a reviewer forced in?
In the 2019 report, Elsevier said it would not retract studies affected by coercive citation, because the authors are not responsible (Singh Chawla, 2019). That was Elsevier's statement about that investigation; the other pages here don't address it.
References
- Elsevier. (n.d.). Your review shapes science. Here's how to do it well. https://www.elsevier.com/publishing/reviewer-guidance/how-to-review
- Sage. (n.d.-a). Citation manipulation policy. Sage Journals. https://www.sagepub.com/journals/publication-ethics-policies/citation-manipulation-policy
- Sage. (n.d.-b). Peer review ethics. Sage Journals. https://www.sagepub.com/journals/information-for-reviewers/peer-review-ethics
- Singh Chawla, D. (2019, September 12). Elsevier investigates hundreds of peer reviewers for manipulating citations. Nature Index. https://www.nature.com/nature-index/news/elsevier-investigates-hundreds-peer-reviewers-for-manipulating-citations
- Taylor & Francis. (n.d.-a). Citations. Taylor & Francis Author Services. https://authorservices.taylorandfrancis.com/editorial-policies/citations/
- Taylor & Francis. (n.d.-b). Misconduct. Taylor & Francis Author Services. https://authorservices.taylorandfrancis.com/editorial-policies/misconduct/
Original article by PerfectRefs. To republish it, credit PerfectRefs and link to this page. Do not edit it or use it commercially.
