

First Submission: Do References Need the Journal's Style?
Not always. Journals that offer format-free submission take the first version's references in any style, as long as you use one style throughout. Elsevier calls the option Your Paper Your Way, Taylor & Francis calls it format-free submission, and Wiley calls it Free Format. Some journals want their own style from the start, and the journal's instructions for authors say which kind yours is. At a format-free journal, the journal's style comes in later, if at all: Taylor & Francis says it reformats accepted papers itself "in most cases," Wiley says it formats accepted papers for you, and Taylor & Francis and Nature say a revision request can come with formatting instructions.
The publisher pages below were read on November 17, 2026, and the example article was checked against its Crossref record the same day.
Which publishers accept references in any style?
| Publisher | What its author page says | How to tell for your journal |
|---|---|---|
| Elsevier | References "can be in any style or format, as long as the style is consistent" | "Every journal that offers YPYW clearly indicates this at the beginning of its Guide for Authors" |
| Taylor & Francis | "Your references can be in any scholarly citation format, so long as you use the same approach throughout the article" | "The instructions for authors for your chosen journal will tell you whether it offers format-free submission"; over 850 journals take part |
| Wiley | "Format your manuscript and your references in the style or format you'd prefer. Be sure to use a consistent format throughout." | "Over 1,100 journals published by Wiley offer Free Format submission"; read the journal's author guidelines |
| IOP Publishing | "you can use any reference system providing it is sensible and consistent throughout the paper" | The journal's "About the journal" page says whether you need "a particular reference style" |
Sources: Elsevier (2026), Taylor & Francis (n.d.), Wiley (n.d.), and IOP Publishing (n.d.-a, n.d.-b).
Nature's initial submission page, a guide to submitting to Nature, says "The Nature journals are flexible with regard to the format of initial submissions" and "Within reason, style and length will not influence consideration of a manuscript." It names no reference style. On the reference list, it asks that "the reference list should include article titles" (Nature, n.d.).
Some journals want their own format at the first submission. The Journal of Clinical Investigation says: "Staff may return a submission if references are not prepared according to Journal format" (The Journal of Clinical Investigation, n.d.). Springer Nature's general advice to authors points the same way: "You will find your target journal's format requirements in its Instructions for Authors," and following them lets the editors evaluate the paper "rather than sending it back to you to be reformatted" (Springer Nature, n.d.). If your journal's guide names a reference style and says nothing about format-free submission, our advice is to format the list in that style before you submit.
What a format-free reference list still needs
Elsevier, Taylor & Francis, Wiley, and IOP Publishing all ask for one style across the whole list. Taylor & Francis and Wiley also list the elements each entry must have:
- Taylor & Francis: "It is essential that you include" author names, the journal or book title, the article or chapter title, the year, the volume and issue where appropriate, and page numbers (Taylor & Francis, n.d.).
- Wiley: authors, journal or book title, "article title (where required)," year, volume and issue or book chapter, and pagination (Wiley, n.d.).
IOP Publishing asks that a reference "give your reader enough information to locate the article" (IOP Publishing, n.d.-b), and Nature asks for article titles. Neither list requires a DOI: Taylor & Francis recommends DOIs, "but they are not mandatory," and Wiley says "including the DOI is highly encouraged."
Here is one complete entry, written in APA 7 (see APA 7 journal article reference):
Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77–101. https://doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa
It has every element on the Taylor & Francis and Wiley lists, plus the DOI. Here is the same reference with the volume, issue, and pages left off:
Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology.
It is in APA 7 and still falls short of both lists.
What "consistent" covers is not spelled out on these pages. Our reading is that the same kind of source should look the same in every entry: the same form of author names and the same order of elements. A list assembled from several places, such as Google Scholar and a coauthor's file, can carry two styles at once.
If you cite with a reference manager, Elsevier's reference page asks you to "remove all field codes before submitting the electronic manuscript" (Elsevier, 2026). Keep a copy of the file with the codes in place, in case the journal asks for its own style later.
When do you have to switch to the journal's style?
Not before the first submission at these publishers. After that, it depends on the publisher.
- Taylor & Francis: "If your article is accepted for publication, in most cases we'll now do all the work of reformatting it to the journal's style." You may occasionally be asked to format your paper "either at the point of acceptance or if you are invited to make revisions," including "formatting references to fit the journal style" (Taylor & Francis, n.d.).
- Wiley: "If your manuscript is accepted for publication, Wiley will format your manuscript for you to match the journal's style" (Wiley, n.d.).
- IOP Publishing: "We will ensure your references adhere to house style during the production process, whatever format you submit them in" (IOP Publishing, n.d.-a).
- Nature: "If revisions are requested, the editor will provide detailed formatting instructions at that time" (Nature, n.d.).
- Elsevier: when Elsevier described the option in 2014, it said "all the journal-specific formatting takes place after acceptance" (Fennell, 2014). Its current reference page doesn't say at which stage, or whether you are asked to do it.
So a request to reformat, if one comes, arrives with a revision request at Nature, and at acceptance or with a revision request at Taylor & Francis. The steps, for citations linked in a reference manager and for a plain-text list, are in how to change citation style for a new journal. The rest of a resubmission is in the revised manuscript checklist.
Check the list before the first submission
Two problems above are worth fixing before you submit: entries in two styles, and entries missing elements the publisher lists. Paste your reference list into PerfectRefs; you don't upload the paper. The Style check compares authors, title, journal, year, volume, issue, pages, and DOI field by field with the database record and shows the record's values with a link to the source. If your entry lacks a field the record has, as the shortened Braun and Clarke entry lacks its volume, issue, and pages, it offers the record's value to accept with one click. It uses premium credits (2 per reference), and new accounts get 10, enough for 5 references. The Existence check, which comes with a free daily allowance, looks up each reference in Crossref, OpenAlex, and other scholarly databases and flags any it can't find.
After the Style check, you can export the list in APA 7, MLA 9, Chicago author-date, IEEE, or Vancouver. Entries copied from different places come out in one style. Only references that went through the Style check are rebuilt, and a reference of a type the chosen style can't rebuild keeps its original text, so read the export before you submit.
If the journal later asks for another style, such as its own house style, the export can't produce it. Export the list as a .ris or .bib file instead. Zotero imports either format (File > Import) and lists over 10,000 additional styles in its Zotero Style Repository, so you can look for the journal's style there (Zotero, 2018, 2026). Keep the exported file with your manuscript: the request may come months after submission, and checking the same references again is free only within 30 days.
FAQ
Do references have to be in the journal's style for the first submission?
Not at journals that offer format-free submission, such as Elsevier journals with Your Paper Your Way, Taylor & Francis format-free journals, and Wiley Free Format journals. Your journal's instructions for authors say whether it does.
Can I mix citation styles in a format-free submission?
No. Each publisher page above that accepts any style asks for one style used throughout.
Do I need DOIs in a format-free submission?
Neither the Taylor & Francis nor the Wiley element list includes one, though both publishers recommend adding it.
References
- Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77–101. https://doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa
- Elsevier. (2026, June 15). How should I prepare the references in my manuscript? Journal Article Publishing Support Center. https://www.elsevier.support/publishing/answer/how-should-i-prepare-the-references-in-my-manuscript
- Fennell, C. (2014, July 23). Your Paper, Your Way: The origins. Elsevier Connect. https://www.elsevier.com/connect/your-paper-your-way-the-origins
- IOP Publishing. (n.d.-a). Style guide for journal articles. IOPscience Publishing Support. https://publishingsupport.iopscience.iop.org/questions/style-guide-journal-articles/
- IOP Publishing. (n.d.-b). Referencing for journal articles. IOPscience Publishing Support. https://publishingsupport.iopscience.iop.org/questions/references/
- The Journal of Clinical Investigation. (n.d.). How to prepare references for submission. https://www.jci.org/kiosks/publish/examples
- Nature. (n.d.). Initial submission. https://www.nature.com/nature/for-authors/initial-submission
- Springer Nature. (n.d.). Formatting. https://www.springernature.com/gp/authors/campaigns/writing-a-manuscript/formatting
- Taylor & Francis. (n.d.). How to submit your manuscript format-free. Taylor & Francis Author Services. https://authorservices.taylorandfrancis.com/publishing-your-research/making-your-submission/format-free-manuscript-submission/
- Wiley. (n.d.). Free Format: Focus on your research. Wiley Author Services. https://authors.aws.wiley.com/author-resources/Journal-Authors/Prepare/free-format-submission.html
- Zotero. (2018, November 4). How do I import BibTeX or other standardized formats? Zotero Documentation. https://www.zotero.org/support/kb/importing_standardized_formats
- Zotero. (2026, July 9). Citation styles. Zotero Documentation. https://www.zotero.org/support/styles
Original article by PerfectRefs. To republish it, credit PerfectRefs and link to this page. Do not edit it or use it commercially.
