

How to Cite a Paper Under Review or In Press: APA and IEEE
It depends on where the paper stands. Accepted but not yet published: APA 7 puts "in press" where the year goes, IEEE writes "to be published," and ICMJE and Taylor & Francis accept "in press" or "forthcoming." Submitted only: IEEE ends the entry with "submitted for publication." ICMJE has it cited in the text as "unpublished observations" with written permission from the source, and Taylor & Francis and Elsevier's Harvard section keep it out of the reference list. Once the paper is out, cite the published version. This page goes deeper into one item of the reference list checklist: entries for papers that aren't published yet.
Sources read on November 17, 2026 (APA's pages in archived copies; IEEE's guide, Version 3.28.2025). The later, published version of IEEE's early-access example was checked against Crossref the same day.
Accepted, under review, or not yet submitted: the rules side by side
| Stage of the paper | APA 7 | IEEE | ICMJE and Taylor & Francis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accepted, not yet published | "in press" in place of the year | to be published | "in press" or "forthcoming" |
| Published online before its issue | The year it appeared online | early access, with the online date and DOI | Not covered on these pages |
| Submitted, not yet accepted | The year it was written, never "submitted for publication" in the date | submitted for publication | In the text, as "unpublished observations" (ICMJE: with the source's written permission; Taylor & Francis: not in the reference list) |
| Still in preparation | The year it was written, never "in progress" | unpublished | In the text, not in the reference list (Taylor & Francis) |
Sources: APA (2025a), IEEE (2025), ICMJE (2026), and Taylor & Francis (n.d.).
The two right-hand columns don't always agree. IEEE puts a submitted paper in the reference list. Taylor & Francis says the same kind of reference "should not be included in the formal reference list." So read the instructions of the journal you are submitting to before you pick a form.
Accepted but not yet published: "in press"
APA's rule: "If a work has been accepted for publication but is not yet published, use the term 'in press' instead of a year" (APA, 2025a). It goes in both places: "For an in-press work, use 'in press' for the date in both the reference list entry and in-text citation" (APA, 2022). So the citation reads (Author, in press).
APA's free pages show the date element only, (in press). For the rest of the entry, the journal article page sends you to Example 8 in the Publication Manual (APA, 2025b). Put together from the date rule and the journal article format, an in-press article reads like this (our assembly, not an APA example):
Author, A. A., & Author, B. B. (in press). Title of the article. Name of the Journal.
The volume, issue, pages, and DOI go in once the article is published.
IEEE gives a full example and a warning (IEEE, 2025, p. 15):
E. H. Miller, "A note on reflector arrays," IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag., to be published.
"Always use this style when the paper has been accepted or scheduled for a future publication but has not been published as early access, i.e., do not use 'to appear in.'"
The ICMJE recommendations say: "References to papers accepted but not yet published should be designated as 'in press' or 'forthcoming'" (ICMJE, 2026). Taylor & Francis says they "should be referred to as 'In Press' or 'Forthcoming' in lieu of publication dates" (Taylor & Francis, n.d.). On Elsevier's reference page, the Harvard section allows in-press articles in the list, and the Vancouver section says "Only articles that have been published or are in press should be included in the references" (Elsevier, 2026).
Published online before its issue: early access and articles in press
An accepted article can go online with a DOI before it has a volume, issue, and pages. IEEE calls this early access (IEEE, 2025, p. 15):
F. Vatta, A. Soranzo, and F. Babich, "More accurate analysis of sum-product decoding of LDPC codes using a Gaussian approximation," IEEE Commun. Lett., early access, Dec. 11, 2018, doi: 10.1109/LCOMM.2018.2886261.
The guide adds: "Always state if the article is early access and include its online version date and DOI. The DOI is essential as it will not change, though the date may." It also says to cite this version and "not the arXiv version" once the publisher has posted it (IEEE, 2025, p. 16). For the preprint side of that choice, see how to cite an arXiv preprint in IEEE.
In APA, "If a work is an advance online publication, use the year of the advance online publication in the reference" (APA, 2025a).
Springer Nature calls the same stage an Article in Press: "an early access version of an accepted, peer-reviewed manuscript" with a permanent DOI. Its advice for citing one: "Use the first online publication year and DOI when referencing them" (Springer Nature, 2026).
Submitted or under review: "submitted for publication" or not at all
APA: "For unpublished, informally published, or in-progress works, provide the year the work was produced. Do not use 'in progress' or 'submitted for publication' in the date element of a reference" (APA, 2025a). The page gives no full entry for a manuscript under review.
IEEE does put the phrase in the entry, at the end (IEEE, 2025, p. 15):
C. K. Kim, "Effect of gamma rays on plasma," submitted for publication.
"Always use this style when the paper has not yet been accepted or scheduled for publication, i.e., do not use 'to appear in.'"
The ICMJE recommendations handle it in the text: "Information from manuscripts submitted but not accepted should be cited in the text as 'unpublished observations' with written permission from the source" (ICMJE, 2026). Taylor & Francis does the same for any findings not yet accepted, placed "within the main text," and gives this sentence as its example: "Our previous study showed metastases recurred in 10% of patients (Unpublished observations)" (Taylor & Francis, n.d.). Elsevier's Harvard section says "articles submitted or in preparation should not be included" in the reference list (Elsevier, 2026).
Not yet submitted: work in preparation
IEEE lists "papers still in preparation" as one of "the two most common types of unpublished references" (IEEE, 2025, p. 21):
B. Smith, "An approach to graphs of linear forms," unpublished.
APA gives it the year it was produced, without "in progress" (APA, 2025a).
When the paper comes out, update the entry
IEEE's early-access example has since been published under the same DOI: according to Crossref, it appeared in volume 23, issue 2, pages 230-233, in February 2019 (Vatta et al., 2019). "Articles published within a volume should use the volume and issue publication date" (IEEE, 2025, p. 4), so the entry becomes:
F. Vatta, A. Soranzo, and F. Babich, "More accurate analysis of sum-product decoding of LDPC codes using a Gaussian approximation," IEEE Commun. Lett., vol. 23, no. 2, pp. 230-233, Feb. 2019, doi: 10.1109/LCOMM.2018.2886261.
Springer Nature describes the same move on its side: when the final version is published, "it will replace the Article in Press, retaining the same DOI" (Springer Nature, 2026). At Springer Nature, then, the DOI you cited for the early version leads to the final one.
Check the updated entries against the published record
Once the paper is out, replace "in press," "to be published," "submitted for publication," or the early-access date with the published details, and check the list after that: an entry still marked in press has no published record to compare with.
In PerfectRefs, you paste your reference list; you don't upload the paper. The Existence check looks up each reference in Crossref, OpenAlex, and other scholarly databases and flags any it can't find. It comes with a free daily allowance. The Style check compares authors, title, journal, year, volume, issue, pages, and DOI field by field with the database record, shows the record's values with a link to the source, and lets you accept a fix with one click, so a volume, issue, or page range you haven't filled in yet can come from the record. APA 7 and IEEE are among the styles you can pick, and articles and books that match a record can then be reformatted and exported. A reference with no matching record gets nothing filled in, and a manuscript under review has none, so check any entry still in one of the forms above by hand against this page. The Style check uses premium credits (2 per reference), and new accounts get 10 premium credits.
A thesis that cites your own papers changes those entries draft after draft, as each paper moves toward print. A thesis pass is one price for the whole thesis, with re-checks free up to its limits; see checking thesis references across drafts.
FAQ
Can I cite a paper that is under review?
It depends on the style and the journal. In IEEE style, it goes in the list as "submitted for publication" (IEEE, 2025). ICMJE has it cited in the text as "unpublished observations" with written permission from the source (ICMJE, 2026). Taylor & Francis also puts it in the text and says it "should not be included in the formal reference list" (Taylor & Francis, n.d.).
Should I write "to appear in"?
Not in IEEE style. The guide says "do not use 'to appear in'" for both accepted and submitted papers (IEEE, 2025, p. 15).
References
- American Psychological Association. (2022, July). Missing reference information. APA Style. https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/references/missing-information
- American Psychological Association. (2025a, October). Elements of reference list entries. APA Style. https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/references/elements-list-entry
- American Psychological Association. (2025b, August). Journal article references. APA Style. https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/references/examples/journal-article-references
- Elsevier. (2026, June 15). How should I prepare the references in my manuscript? Journal Article Publishing Support Center. https://www.elsevier.support/publishing/answer/how-should-i-prepare-the-references-in-my-manuscript
- IEEE. (2025). IEEE reference style guide for authors (Version 3.28.2025). https://docs.google.com/document/d/e/2PACX-1vSBoV_hTIURPZKtQkxI6bAONJtjyDLxQIUvCHi-XPzD8NKLcxRfZrpvQLFrjWZ3M6FFR_Obau3R-t63/pub
- International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. (2026). Recommendations for the conduct, reporting, editing, and publication of scholarly work in medical journals. https://www.icmje.org/icmje-recommendations.pdf
- Springer Nature. (2026, October 6). What is an Article in Press? Springer Nature Support. https://support.springernature.com/en/support/solutions/articles/6000281821-what-is-an-article-in-press
- Taylor & Francis. (n.d.). Citations. Taylor & Francis Author Services. https://authorservices.taylorandfrancis.com/editorial-policies/citations/
- Vatta, F., Soranzo, A., & Babich, F. (2019). More accurate analysis of sum-product decoding of LDPC codes using a Gaussian approximation. IEEE Communications Letters, 23(2), 230–233. https://doi.org/10.1109/LCOMM.2018.2886261
Original article by PerfectRefs. To republish it, credit PerfectRefs and link to this page. Do not edit it or use it commercially.
